I just saw Opera Birmingham’s performance of Faust. (My second opera!) As with most things, it’s not about what you might think.
“Did any human anytime ever just say what he or she meant? What would happen if we did?”
Snippets of this classic fable appear in everything from Harold Ramis movies to iCarly. We meet Faust in the first act. He’s a crusty old scoundrel. Antisocial, suicidal, and infernal. In cursing his plight and life, he carelessly asks for Satan. And gets him.
“Satan, come to me!” “Here I am!”
Mephistopheles offers Faust gold, glory, and power – you know the deal – in exchange for his soul. Faust, though, only wants to be young again, lusting for the caresses of young mistresses.
“Youth is like having a big plate of candy. Sentimentalists think they want to be in the pure, simple state they were in before they ate the candy. They don’t. They just want the fun of eating it all over again. The matron doesn’t want to repeat her girlhood – she wants to repeat her honeymoon. I don’t want to repeat my innocence. I want the pleasure of losing it again.”
Mephistopheles shows Faust a vision of blonde, beautiful Marguerite and he wants her.
“Lois looked edible, and you knew it was tender all the way through, a kind of mystic combination of filet mignon and a Georgia peach aching for the tongue and ready to bleed gold.”
No stronger than his baser desires, Faust gives in to the devil’s pitch and his own lustful fantasies of bedding the blonde. He signs the contract. Satan keeps his end of the bargain and transforms him back into a young man.
“[He] told us about one of Plato’s dialogues, in which an old man is asked how it felt not to be excited by sex anymore. The old man replies that it was like being allowed to dismount from a wild horse.“ You know, “ven der putz shteht, ligt der sechel in drerd.”
That’s the first act, but the opera isn’t really about Faust. It’s not about Satan, either. It’s about the girl. Kind-of like how the Star Wars franchise took twenty years to tell us that the story wasn’t really about Luke Skywalker. No, it was all about Vader.
“You are on an evil path.”
Like a Disney princess, Marguerite is the purest and goodest of good girls. Even her brother (and every cross-dresser in town) is completely in love with her. She’s beautiful, yet humble. Her flaw is just that she gets attacked by forces beyond her control. The first question newly-young Faust asks is, “Where’s the blonde?”
Mephistopheles contrives to have them meet and conjures a box of shiny jewelry for Faust to give. She is tempted by Faust’s jewels – aided by the devil’s enchantment – and falls in love.
“In all the green world nothing feels as good as a woman’s good nature.”
The moral of the story: If he’s charming, irresistable, and brings expensive gifts, beware. He may have brokered a deal with the devil to get you.
“Don’t give that kiss, girl, until the ring is on your finger.”
Even though the magic of the devil backs Faust’s wooing, Marguerite still tries to resist. Faust claims love – though I don’t believe him for a moment – and Marguerite tries to think of a way to make sure. It reminds me of Meatloaf: “Do you love me? Will you love me forever?” “Let me sleep on it, baby, baby.”
“How can I resist such a temptation?”
It’s opera, so there’s fallout. She buys it. He beds her. She’s knocked up. After getting exactly what he was after all along, Faust R-U-N-N-O-F-T. I like to imagine him partying like Charlie Sheen in the time between acts. Marguerite is ostracized. Her brother damns her to hell. She kills the baby – yes, she kills Satan’s baby – and is put in prison. Faust feels guilty – not like real guilty – but kinda. Marguerite finally figures out that he’s a scumbag and dies, not damned at all, but forgiven and ascending to heaven in spite of the devil’s manipulation.
“With Satan, you should behave better.”
Let’s put in some straight talk here. It’s not about what you think it’s about. I’ve seen two operas and both were all about sex. Not love. S-E-X. Faust (Bryan Hymel) wants to score with a young blonde and – unless I’m missing something – it would be a mistake to play him any other way. No matter how much he rationalizes, I don’t buy that he’s in love. Sure there’s pretty music and pretty singing, but opera, funnily enough, is more like country music than some might care to admit. It’s about heartbreak and badonkadonk and drinking your troubles away.
Speaking of drinking, this performance had some wonderful little moments. Mephistopheles (beautifully played by Kirk Eichelberger) turns water into wine in front of everyone. Also, he makes a surprise appearance out of an onstage coffin and gets the biggest laugh of the night. I didn’t expect for the pipe organ at Samford’s Wright Center to get any use, but it was appropriate and worked. Lastly, I’m not sure if the rest of the audience knew it was happening, but Opera Birmingham used the Samford A Cappella Choir in the balcony for, at least, the final act – behind or above the audience on the floor – and creating a sophisticated, lush, and celestial experience. Absolutely A+. I wish I could push a button and have it play again.
Sincerest thank yous to John D. Jones and everyone at Opera Birmingham.